Best Christmas Murder Mysteries: 13 Cozy, Clever Picks
Planning your holiday TBR? Discover 13 Christmas murder mystery books—from cozy whodunits to classic detectives—with quick who-it’s-for notes and mini reviews.
Christmas Crime to Curl Up With: 13 Festive Whodunits
Key takeaway: If you want one surefire crowd-pleaser, start with Hercule Poirot’s Christmas (classic locked-room perfection). For modern, funny, and interactive? The Christmas Appeal. Need something dark and atmospheric? Ashes in the Snow. Prefer ultra-cozy? A Christmas Candy Killing or the Christmas Mittens Murder trio.
I love a December Christmas read with clues, cocoa, and a little snow squeaking underfoot. Below you’ll find 13 Christmas murder mystery and thriller books I actually recommend-each in one quick, spoiler-aware paragraph that covers what it’s about, the character journey/message, why I picked it, who it’s for (think “readers who like…”), and how it left me feeling.
13 Christmas Murder Mystery Books
Classic Christmas Crime Stories by David Stuart Davies
A golden-age stocking of ten festive whodunits where butlers, vicars, and houseguests hide more than presents; the joy here is watching clever amateurs and cool-headed inspectors restore order when tradition and motive collide. I chose it because short stories are perfect for busy nights. For readers who like Christie-era puzzles, trains, snowed-in houses, and neat reveals; I felt pleasantly smug every time I spotted a clue in time.
The Christmas Guest by Peter Swanson
An American art student spends Christmas in a picture-perfect English village and discovers the gloss hides old rot; this is a diary-style descent into “how well do you know your hosts?” that asks what curiosity costs. I picked it for the creeping dread delivered in a tight package. For readers who like Ruth Ware vibes and rural secrets; it left me deliciously unsettled-like hearing a footstep on fresh snow behind you.
A Christmas Candy Killing by Christina Romeril
Twin sisters run a mystery-themed chocolate shop until a local true-crime maven turns up dead; our amateur sleuth balances grief, community gossip, and cocoa-dusted clues while deciding who-and what-she wants to protect. I chose it because it’s peak cozy without saccharine overload. For readers who like Joanne Fluke/Laura Childs, small-town settings, recipes, and low-gore; I finished comforted and a little hungry.
Hercule Poirot’s Christmas by Agatha Christie
A tyrannical patriarch summons his squabbling family, the snow falls, the room locks, and a very bloody body poses a very clean puzzle; Poirot nudges vanity and grudges until truth surfaces. I included it because it’s the quintessential holiday locked-room. For readers who love classic deduction and razor-fair clues; I felt that fizzy “of course!” click at the reveal.
The Christmas Appeal by Janice Hallett
Told via emails, texts, and flyers, a village theatre group mounts a Christmas panto while theft (and worse) lurks backstage; the real fun is playing armchair detective as the paper trail contradicts itself. I chose it for the interactive feel and warm satire. For readers who like epistolary mysteries, Only Murders humor, and community chaos; I grinned my way through and immediately wanted to re-read for missed hints.
Ashes in the Snow by Oriana Ramunno
In Auschwitz, 1943, a forensic investigation forces a damaged detective to face what justice can mean amid atrocity; the case is propulsive, but the heart is moral clarity under impossible winter skies. I picked it because it respects history while still delivering a taut mystery. For readers who like Louise Penny’s humanity with darker stakes; I closed the book hushed and reflective.
The Christmas Murder Game by Alexandra Benedict
A sprawling manor, a will with riddles, and twelve days of increasingly dangerous “games” test a heroine who must out-think her murderous family history to claim her legacy. I chose it for the Clue-like puzzles and full-tilt festive menace. For readers who love treasure-hunt clues and country-house peril; it left me happily breathless and reaching for mince pies.
Christmas Mittens Murder by Lee Hollis, Lynn Cahoon, Maddie Day
Three novella-length cozies where handmade mittens tangle with murder, giving beloved series sleuths bite-size holiday cases and personal stakes (careers, friendships, new beginnings). I included it because short cozies are perfect between parties. For readers who like series samplers, craft themes, and low-angst crime; I felt cozy, stitched-in, and satisfied.
Hercule Poirot’s Silent Night by Sophie Hannah
Poirot and Catchpool accept an odd invitation to a cliff-top house where grief and secrets curdle into a very seasonal crime; the emotional arc explores loyalty and the stories families tell themselves. I chose it because Hannah captures Poirot’s compassion as well as his “little grey cells.” For readers who enjoy new-canon Poirot with modern psychology; I felt soothed by the order Poirot restores.
Murder at an Irish Christmas by Carlene O’Connor
Restaurant owner Siobhán O’Sullivan heads to West Cork for a festive concert turned crime scene, balancing romance, family, and a tangle of local grievances as she follows the evidence. I picked it for Irish Christmas atmosphere and sibling banter. For readers who like village cozies with heart; I finished warm, like stepping back inside the pub after a cold walk.
The Christmas Thief by Mary Higgins Clark
A sparkling Rockefeller Center heist entwines with an upstate caper as two generations of sleuths chase a tree (and a thief) across holiday New York; the message is teamwork and second chances. I included it for a lighter, caper-y change of pace. For readers who like clean suspense with humor; I felt buoyant and very “city at Christmas.”
The Twelve Clues of Christmas by Rhys Bowen
Lady Georgie takes refuge in a Devon village hosting daily “twelve days” festivities…until bodies begin to tally; she must grow past decorative guest to capable sleuth, and it’s charming watching her claim her agency. I chose it for festive tradition meets fair-play puzzle. For readers who enjoy Royal Spyness or historical cozy romps; I ended cheerful and team-Georgie forever.
A Maigret Christmas: And Other Stories by Georges Simenon, Translated by David Coward
Nine gentle mini-mysteries, including Maigret trying to preserve a child’s wonder while quietly pursuing truth; these are about compassion as much as solution. I picked it because sometimes you want small stakes, big heart. For readers who like character-led, smoky-café vibes; I felt calm and oddly Christmassy.
Quick Picks by Mood
- Classic locked room: Hercule Poirot’s Christmas
- Cozy & low-gore: A Christmas Candy Killing • Christmas Mittens Murder
- Play-along puzzles: The Christmas Appeal • The Christmas Murder Game
- Dark & thoughtful: Ashes in the Snow
- Festive caper: The Christmas Thief
- Short on time: Classic Christmas Crime Stories • A Maigret Christmas
Fast FAQ (because readers ask)
What’s the difference between a thriller and a murder mystery?
Mystery = puzzle (who/why/how) with clues leading to a reveal. Thriller = imminent danger and momentum; the “who” may be known early, the suspense is “will they stop it?”
What makes a cozy mystery “cozy”?
Amateur sleuth, close-knit setting, off-page violence, and community/character beats as important as the case. Think puzzle over gore.
A few ways to use this list
- Buddy read: pick one classic + one modern and compare the clueing.
- Book club add-ons: bake-off (best ginger biscuit) or “bring a clue” icebreaker.
- Reading sprint: choose three short stories from Classic Christmas Crime Stories and time your guesses.
Final Thoughts
What do you think about these Christmas murder mystery books? Have you read any books from this list? What are your favorite Christmas murder mystery books? What books would you add to the list? Let’s talk all about Christmas murder mysteries in the comments below.
Want To Save This Post?
Enter your email below & I'll send it straight to your inbox. Plus you'll get themed lists and posts from me every week!
